Designing AI for ROI
Automation First, Intelligence Where It Pays
Artificial Intelligence is often described as transformative, disruptive, or revolutionary.
In reality, AI is something far simpler.
It is delegation.
When organisations deploy AI, they are delegating certain tasks away from humans and into systems. The problem is not that AI is ineffective. The problem is that many organisations are delegating the wrong type of work.
And that is where ROI disappears.
The Core Design Mistake
Across insurance and financial services, a common pattern emerges:
- High-volume, predictable work is routed into AI models
- Compute costs increase
- Governance becomes complex
- Confidence weakens
- Returns become unclear
At the same time, straightforward automation opportunities remain untouched.
The result is an expensive AI estate solving problems that did not require intelligence in the first place.
AI is powerful when applied to judgement, ambiguity and pattern recognition.
It is wasteful when used for predictable volume.
The Right Delegation Model
The most effective organisations follow a simple hierarchy:
- Automate the predictable
If a task is repeatable and rules-based, automate it.
Examples in insurance and financial services include:
-
- Policy validation checks
- Claims processing steps
- Reconciliations and bordereaux validation
- Regulatory and financial reporting preparation
- System-to-system data movement
Robotic Process Automation and deterministic workflows handle this efficiently and at low cost.
This removes operational friction before intelligence is introduced.
- Use analytics to guide decisions
Once processes are automated, analytics provides structured insight:
-
- Portfolio performance
- Pricing trends
- Loss ratios
- Risk segmentation
- Operational bottlenecks
This layer ensures decisions are informed by trusted data rather than intuition.
- Apply AI only where judgement is required
AI and GenAI add value when ambiguity exists:
-
- Fraud detection
- Underwriting exceptions
- Claims triage
- Customer interaction intelligence
- Complex anomaly detection
This is where machine learning and large language models justify their compute cost.
AI should handle exceptions.
Automation should handle volume.
Why RPA Quietly Delivers the Fastest ROI
RPA rarely generates headlines.
It does, however, consistently deliver measurable returns:
- Lower infrastructure cost
- Reduced manual effort
- Faster turnaround times
- Clear audit trails
- Lower governance burden
In many organisations, RPA eliminates thousands of hours of manual work annually. That capacity can then be redirected toward higher-value activity.
When RPA is implemented before AI, it:
- Improves data quality
- Reduces noise in downstream models
- Limits unnecessary AI usage
- Creates cleaner operational workflows
This sequencing dramatically improves total cost of ownership.
The Hidden Cost of Misapplied AI
When AI is applied indiscriminately:
- GPU and cloud costs rise
- Latency increases
- Model monitoring requirements expand
- Regulatory scrutiny intensifies
- Complexity compounds
In regulated industries, this is not simply a technical issue. It becomes a governance and risk issue.
The organisations seeing sustainable returns are not anti-AI.
They are disciplined about where AI belongs.
Creating a Culture of Execution Discipline
Execution discipline is cultural as much as technical.
It requires:
- Starting with business decisions, not technology selection
- Designing for cost and auditability from the outset
- Embedding ownership within underwriting, claims, finance and operations
- Rewarding simplification rather than architectural complexity
- Measuring ROI in operational outcomes, not pilot activity
In many organisations, complexity is mistaken for sophistication.
In reality, simplicity is often the most advanced design choice.
The Practical Question Every Leader Should Ask
Before investing further in AI, leaders should ask:
- Are we automating everything that is predictable?
- Are we using analytics to guide decisions consistently?
- Are we reserving AI for judgement and exception handling?
- Are we paying premium compute cost for work that could be deterministic?
If the answer to the last question is yes, the issue is not capability.
It is delegation design.
Final Thought
AI is not magic.
It is a tool for delegating complexity.
Used with discipline, it drives growth, protects the firm and improves operational efficiency.
Used without discipline, it increases cost and scrutiny without increasing confidence.
The organisations seeing real ROI are not chasing hype.
They are optimising what they already own.
That is how AI scales safely, affordably and credibly.
